Republican Representative Ginny Brown-Waite of Florida sent a letter to the White House this past week (pdf by way of the St. Petersburg Times' Buzz blog). Two other Republican members of the House signed off on it—Cliff Stearns of Florida and Ron Paul of Texas. They are, it turns out, concerned, concerned President Obama respect the Constitution and ask Congress for approval before he accepts the 2009 Nobel Peace Prize, just like Teddy Roosevelt did.
I would like to take this opportunity to urge you to follow in the footsteps of a great American President and one of the first recipients of a Nobel Peace Prize, Theodore Roosevelt, and fulfill your Constitutional obligation to obtain Congress' consent before formally accepting the Nobel Prize.
Artice I, Section 9 of the Constitution clearly states: "no person holding any office of profit or trust under them, shall, without the consent of the Congress, accept of any present, emolument, office, or title, of any kind whatever, from any king, prince, or foreign state." As the Nobel Peace Prize is awarded by a committee appointed by the Parliament of Norway, the Storting, the prize is clearly subject to the requirement set forth in Article I, Section 9 of the Constitution. Obtaining permission from Congress should be straightforward.
The letter makes no mention of Woodrow Wilson, who also won the prize while President, nor cites the political theory upon which they base their expansive understanding of a foreign state.
Cliff Stearns
has further concerns.
"Let's say you had a nonprofit in the Mideast that gave him a large sum of money, would we want that?" Stearns said. "The president should be careful about accepting gifts while in office."
Non-profit organizations are now states. Good to know.
Where did Brown-Waite and her colleagues get this idea?
Brown-Waite said she got the idea from an aide, who read something on a blog right after the announcement.
Behold the power of the blogosphere. The internet makes you stupid. Both axioms apply here.
Not to be outdone by citizen-journalist-pundits, the
Washington Post, in its continuing effort to give voice to right-wingers and tick off
thunder, two weeks ago published an
op-ed piece by two law professors in which they make the same argument. They even have a suggestion for how Congress—not Obama—should use the prize money: apply it "to some worthy cause, such as reducing the deficit."
That's exactly what Gandhi would have done if he had ever won the Peace Prize.